background image
Implementation process
Governance structures
Public-private partnerships are essential for the success of smart
city projects. A balanced partnership allows leveraging more
resources, gathering sufficient financial support and securing
institutional authority.
5. "YOU ARE SMART BUT. . ."
Cities will continue to develop while refining their economic
and social strategies; "smart" will no longer be an edge a city
is characterized by, but rather the essence upon which this city
operates. Yet, getting smarter comes with a set of challenges
hindering the process and implementation.
Standardization challenge
Smart city initiatives must be tailored to specific conditions, local
resources, infrastructure, integrating technology, city government,
and stakeholders: there are no off-the-shelf solutions.
Synergies between sectors
Smart is about performing sustainable activities in an integrated
fashion. The involvement of multiple partners/parties on one
project and the alignment of their priorities beyond a political
or private vision are key in smart cities. The move from the
individual private vision to a holistic planning is the challenge.
Financial challenge
A set of issues needs to be addressed in order to achieve the
better implementation and financial success of the city.
Who do you want to attract? Who provides funding? Will the
people want to pay and how? Can they afford it?
Governance challenge
The most critical issue is the following:
How is a smart city governed? With all the real-time e-services
provided to citizens, who will own the networks and data?
Who should be able to exploit these data?
Assessing the full benefit/risk of data and winning end users' trust
in this digital world is a key challenge. Ensuring security, privacy
and data integrity for every user is key to the successful adoption
of e-services.
Build the partnerships
to deliver holistic
soluions
Use digital modelling to
provide a people-centered
physical environment
Put in place an enabling
digital and communications
Infrastructure
Develop and test
new models and
processes
Build the foundation
for widespread
exploitation of data
The concept of smart cities is challenged today, and will definitely be
more challenged with its frequent implementation in the years to come.
Similarly to all experimentation lead on cities throughout the centuries
and particularly after the industrial revolution, the practice of smart
cities will fail and succeed, and will manage to set lessons learnt for a
better practice. Meanwhile, governments, businesses and citizens need to
progressively adapt to this track change in the urban history of cities.
Project led by private sector companies
e.g., Songdo, South Korea / PlanIT Valley,
Portugal
· Lack of institutional authority
· Lack of support from the government
bank
Project led by a single government
e.g., Masdar City
· Clear leader
· Considerable funding via
state-owned banks
· Cooperation between public and
private parties hindered
Project led by dual government joint
ventures
e.g., Sino-Singapore Tianjin Eco-City /
Amsterdam Smart City
· More resources leveraged
· Hindered cooperation between public
and private parties
15
Smart urbanism
|
i10